The Environmental Audit Committee (EAC) is pushing for a review of key initiatives within the UK’s net zero strategy for aviation, citing concerns about their effectiveness and potential shortcomings.
Published in December, the EAC shared a string of recommendations based on feedback from academics, professional bodies, manufacturers, NGOs, representatives from the finance, aviation, and shipping industries and Government advisers.
The inquiry, originally launched in March 2021, sought to evaluate the government’s approach to decarbonising aviation and shipping, two sectors identified as particularly challenging due to their high emissions footprint (approximately 10% of the UK’s total).
Since then, the government has published its Jet Zero Strategy, which aims to deliver net zero aviation by 2050 through a number of initiatives such as investing in technological advancements, improving system efficiencies, and consumer engagement
Despite this, the recently released EAC report argues that further action is needed.
The fuel of the future
One key area of concern is the reliance on Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF) to reach net zero in the sector. The International Air Transport Association (IATA) estimates that emissions from SAFs are between 70% and 80% lower than those from conventional aviation fuel.
Read next: Virgin Atlantic completes world’s first ‘SAF’ transatlantic flight
The UK government is aiming to become a ‘world leader’ in SAF production, and for the fuel to contribute 10% of aviation fuel by 2030, increasing to 70% by 2050. Today, SAF contributes to less than 1% of UK demand.
However, the responses to the committee raise concerns about the wide variation in lifecycle emissions of different SAF categories. Therefore, the committee emphasises the need for a globally recognised definition of “sustainable” in the context of SAF, in order to guarantee that domestically produced SAF actually complies with sustainability criteria.
Additionally, to truly jumpstart a domestic SAF industry, the authors urge the government to match its ambitions with an equal dose of risk tolerance and innovation. They specifically recommend swift implementation of a price support mechanism to incentivise investment in SAF production pathways.
Reducing demand
Another area the committee recognises is that of “demand management.” This approach proposes that reducing the overall demand for air travel will directly lower the number of flights and, consequently, emissions.
In its June 2023 report to Parliament, the Climate Change Committee (CCC) advised that “demand management is the most effective way of reducing aviation CO2 and non-CO2 emissions”. The CCC pointed to the options available to the Government to manage demand, including promotion of the use of digital technologies, addressing the current use of private flying and provision of lower-cost domestic rail travel,
However, industry representatives disagreed with this statement, with Andy Jefferson, programme director at Sustainable Aviation telling the committee that, “[it is] not fair and equitable. It is not solving the problem, and it is probably not helping industry invest in innovation, so it is a triple negative in some regards.”
One solution put forward to the EAC by climate action charity, Possible, was the concept of a ‘frequent flyer levy’ — a progressive tax which increases per flight someone takes or per mile that they fly. The purpose of the levy is to discourage the frequent flying.
Possible believes a levy is the only fiscal policy measure which could reduce aviation demand in a way which decreased rather than exacerbated existing high levels of inequality in access to flights.
Aviations place in the UK’s carbon budget
The UK boasts a series of laws that limit how much greenhouse gas it can release each five years, called “carbon budgets.” In 2021, under Boris Johnson, the government pledged to include international aviation emissions in the UK’s Sixth Carbon Budget, which covers the period from 2033 to 2037.
But, despite over two and a half years since the commitment, legislation to give effect to this commitment has not been brought forward for approval. The commitment was originally promised to legislate “within twelve months.”
Therefore, the EAC recommends the government lay before Parliament for approval a draft to ensure that emissions from international aviation and international shipping are officially recognised under future budgets.
The Government is expected to respond to the EAC’s report in early 2024.





